Warning: This page uses Cascading Style Sheets. We recommend you upgrade to a current version of your favourite browser.

Succinic Acidcposs logo

Back to:

Ordered alphabetically by REFCODE Ordered alphabetically by Common name Ordered by molecular formula Grouped by family

Succinic Acid

(Last updated October 2024)

Molecular diagram of Succinic Acid

Figure 1. The molecular diagram of Succinic Acid.

CSP studies

Two sets of searches were carried out by Louise Price, one of which was written up in the publication on the gamma form.1 The difference between these searches was in the method of generating the database of LAM points for the CrystalPredictor search. The published search is called search A and the unpublished search is called search B.

A further search was caried out by Luca Iuzzolino as part of his PhD work on the CCDC’s Conformer Generator tool.2 This was not included in the paper though. This search is called C.

Early work was also carried out by Nizar Issa as part of his work on cocrystals of succinic acid.3 This search is called D, and included Z’=1 and Z’=2 searches with the planar conformation only.

1. P. Lucaioli, E. Nauha, I. Gimondi, L. S. Price, R. Guo, L. Iuzzolino, I. Singh, M. Salvalaglio, S. L. Price and N. Blagden, CrystEngComm, 2018, 20, 3971-3977.

2. L. Iuzzolino, A. M. Reilly, P. McCabe and S. L. Price, Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation, 2017, 13, 5163-5171.

3. N. Issa, S. A. Barnett, S. Mohamed, D. E. Braun, R. C. B. Copley, D. A. Tocher and S. L. Price, CrystEngComm, 2012, 14, 2454-2464.

REFCODE
SUCACB
Download Word Document
FormulaC4 H6 O4
Common NameSuccinic Acid
IUPAC Systematic NameButanedioic acid
Other Names
CSD RefcodesSUCACB03, SUCACB07, SUCACB19
 
Search Identifier
A
Open Chemiscope file Opens in a new tab - please be patient.
ScientistLouise Price
Date2018
PublicationP Lucaioli, E Nauha, I Gimondi, LS Price, R Guo, L Iuzzolino, I Singh, M Salvalaglio, SL Price, N Blagden, CrystEngComm 2018, 20, 3971-3977.
Energy model
2
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID13
ProgramsStudy_ID=23, CrystalOptimizer (2.4.4), DMACRYS (2.2.1.0)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcid\CrystalOptimizer_bestLAM
Potential DescriptionCrystalOptimizer with GDMA2.2(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p)) + FIT
Intramolecular Description PBE0/6-31G(d,p)
Energy model
1
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID23
ProgramsFlexible CrystalPredictor (2.2), DMACRYS (2.2.1.0)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcid\CrystalPredictor_bestLAM
Potential DescriptionCrystalPredictor + DMACRYS with GDMA2.2(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p)) + FIT
Intramolecular Description PBE1PBE(6-31G(d,p))
Energy model
3
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID33
ProgramsStudy_ID=13, DMACRYS (2.2.0.1)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcid\PCM_bestLAM
Potential DescriptionGDMA2.2(PCMdielectric3(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p))) + FIT
Intramolecular Description PCM3(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p))
 
Search Identifier
B
Open Chemiscope file Opens in a new tab - please be patient.
ScientistLouise Price
Date2018
PublicationSee Study_ID=13
Energy model
2
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID12
ProgramsStudy_ID=22, CrystalOptimizer (2.4.4), DMACRYS (2.2.1.0)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcid\CrystalOptimizer_Uintra0
Potential DescriptionCrystalOptimizer with GDMA2.2(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p)) + FIT
Intramolecular Description PBE0/6-31G(d,p)
Energy model
1
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID22
ProgramsFlexible CrystalPredictor (2.2), DMACRYS (2.2.1.0)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcid\CrystalPredictor_Uintra0
Potential DescriptionCrystalPredictor + DMACRYS with GDMA2.2(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p)) + FIT
Intramolecular Description PBE1PBE(6-31G(d,p))
Energy model
3
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID32
ProgramsStudy_ID=12, DMACRYS (2.2.0.1)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcid\PCM_Uintra0
Potential DescriptionGDMA2.2(PCMdielectric3(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p))) + FIT
Intramolecular Description PCM3(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p))
 
Search Identifier
C
Open Chemiscope file Opens in a new tab - please be patient.
ScientistLuca Iuzzolino
Date2018
PublicationSee Study_ID=13
Energy model
1
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID11
ProgramsRigid CrystalPredictor (unknown), CrystalOptimizer (2.4.4), DMACRYS (2.2.1.0)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcid\Conformer_Generator\CrystalOptimizer
Potential DescriptionCrystalOptimizer with GDMA2.2(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p)) + FIT
Intramolecular Description PBE0/6-31G(d,p)
Energy model
2
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID31
ProgramsStudy_ID=11, DMACRYS (2.2.1.0)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcid\Conformer_Generator\PCM
Potential DescriptionGDMA2.2(PCMdielectric3(PBE1PBE/6-31G(d,p))) + FIT
Intramolecular Description PCM/6-31G(d,p)
 
Search Identifier
D
Open Chemiscope file Opens in a new tab - please be patient.
ScientistNizar Issa
Date2012
PublicationN Issa, SA Barnett, S Mohamed, DE Braun, RCB Copley, DA Tocher, SL Price, CrystEngComm, 2012, 14, 2454-2464
Energy model
2
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID10
ProgramsStudy_ID=20, CrystalOptimizer, DMACRYS (2.0.2)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcidCocrystals\Succinic_CO
Potential DescriptionCrystalOptimizer HF/6-31G(d,p) Intra, GDMA2.2(MP2/6-31G(d,p)) DMA + FIT
Intramolecular Description HF/6-31G(d,p)
Energy model
1
Download all .res files and spreadsheet (single .zip)
Study_ID20
ProgramsRigid CrystalPredictor (1.x), DMACRYS (2.0.2)
Location on S Drive\CHEMISTRY_CPOSS\SuccinicAcidCocrystals\Succinic
Potential DescriptionRigid CrystalPredictor + MP2 6-31G(d,p) DMA +FIT
Intramolecular DescriptionMP2/6-31G(d,p)

Lattice Energy Landscape of Succinic Acid. Energy model A2 Lattice Energy Landscape of Succinic Acid. Energy model D1

Figure 2. Lattice Energy Landscapes of Succinic Acid. Energy models A2 and D1.

Some tetragonal crystal structures did not have unit cell parameters consistent with the spacegroup. These were adjusted in the .res files to make them consistent. (Always Z’>1 structures in the CrystalOptimizer refinements.) The cell parameters in the Excel spreadsheets are taken from the .sum files, so these are the incorrect output numbers. The structures affected were A2: A3733 and A8441. B2: A3168, A4647, A7951. These were also edited in the PCM structures. Some A2 crystal structures did not appear in the A1 set of structures. This affected a significant proportion. It is probable that clustering or energy limits were not introduced to the CrystalPredictor search until after CrystalOptimizer was run on all the structures. This does not affect search B.

CSD structures (CSD version 5.45 with Mar Jun and Sep updates)

Table 1. Crystallographic information and experimental information of CSD entries for Succinic Acid. Different polymorphs, as ascertained by structure matching of 20 molecule coordination sphere in Mercury, are coloured differently. Reference polymorphs are outlined in bold.

REFCODESpacegroupZ'a / Åb / Åc / Åα / °β / °γ / °density / g cm-3FormR factorT / KYearComment / referenceREFCODE
SUCACB01P-11.06.850007.225.72109.4396.67101.550.0triclinic alpha polymorphNoneNone194410.1002/recl.19440630902SUCACB01
SUCACB02P21/c0.55.5198.8625.10190.091.5990.01.5725monoclinic beta polymorph3.300None198110.1107/S0567740881008352SUCACB02
SUCACB03P21/c0.55.4648.7665.0040090.093.2990.01.6389monoclinic beta polymorph2.7at 77 K198110.1107/S0567740881008352SUCACB03
SUCACB04P-11.05.726.850007.57106.16116.0000083.330.0triclinic alpha polymorphNoneNone1983NoneSUCACB04
SUCACB05P21/a0.55.1268.887.61990.0133.690.00.0monoclinic beta polymorphNoneNone1983NoneSUCACB05
SUCACB06P21/a0.55.0988.8795.520190.091.5390.01.5701monoclinic beta polymorph4.0None1998NoneSUCACB06
SUCACB07P-11.06.8677.1985.727109.1000097.18101.843.0627triclinic alpha polymorph6.3None1998NoneSUCACB07
SUCACB08P21/c0.55.477308.78975.026990.092.90590.01.6225monoclinic beta polymorph4.54at 130 K200010.1016/S0022-2860(99)00293-8SUCACB08
SUCACB09P21/c0.55.476908.78175.0280090.092.92890.01.6238monoclinic beta polymorph4.87at 130 K200010.1021/ja0011459SUCACB09
SUCACB10P21/a0.55.1268.887.61990.0133.690.01.5615monoclinic beta polymorph12.4None195910.1098/rspa.1959.0118SUCACB10
SUCACB11P21/c0.55.526108.880705.105190.091.4990.01.5658monoclinic beta polymorph4.23None200010.1021/ja0011459SUCACB11
SUCACB12P21/a0.55.09938.87635.519890.091.50890.01.5702monoclinic beta polymorph4.2298 K201310.1021/cg400668wSUCACB12
SUCACB13P21/a0.55.0758.843205.507290.091.87890.01.5875monoclinic beta polymorph4.01260 K201310.1021/cg400668wSUCACB13
SUCACB14P21/a0.55.05648.811305.486690.092.2590.01.6055monoclinic beta polymorph3.66220 K201310.1021/cg400668wSUCACB14
SUCACB15P21/a0.55.04428.7945.479390.092.50290.01.6150monoclinic beta polymorph3.39180 K201310.1021/cg400668wSUCACB15
SUCACB16P21/a0.55.028708.783105.476890.092.86200090.01.6232monoclinic beta polymorph3.37140 K201310.1021/cg400668wSUCACB16
SUCACB17P21/a0.55.02058.7685.4662090.093.04390.01.6321monoclinic beta polymorph3.61120 K201310.1021/cg400668wSUCACB17
SUCACB18P21/c0.55.47438.774005.031990.092.81990.01.6246monoclinic beta polymorph2.71150 K201510.1002/asia.201500322SUCACB18
SUCACB19C2/c0.55.70158.415410.353890.090.37490.01.5789monoclinic gamma polymorph4.72173 K201810.1039/C8CE00625CSUCACB19
SUCACB20P21/a0.55.100008.887.6190.0133.690.01.5713monoclinic beta polymorph22.0None194910.1039/JR9490000980SUCACB20
SUCACB21P21/c0.55.516908.885.098790.091.49390.01.5705monoclinic beta polymorph5.029296.1 K2024NoneSUCACB21

The Word Document contains some crystallization information.

 

© UCL Chemistry Department 2022. This page was last updated on 30 Sep 2026. If you have any problems with this page please email the WebMaster